Carnival Critique
On this page 1 section ›
This concept page does not yet have synthesis content. The extractor flagged it as a load-bearing concept; a future synthesis pass will populate it. The All Occurrences section below shows every place it appears in the corpus.
All occurrences
Where it appears in the corpus (1)
-
#01
Only a Joke Can Save Us: A Theory of Comedy · Todd McGowan · p.181
Ideology and Equality > Faking Critique
Theoretical move: Comedy that appears to target authority can serve ideological functions by positioning the authority figure as a "substantial subject" who can afford self-mockery, thereby reinforcing rather than undermining the symbolic structure that sustains power; this argument extends Bakhtin's carnival critique to show how comic subversion—even when sincere—enables authority to function more efficiently rather than challenging it.
Pierce and McIntyre exhibit precisely the defects of Bakhtin's carnival as a political strategy. Their humor, even when it targets military authority, does not disturb that authority.